The Library


Search Library

Does the "No-Contact Rule" Apply with Respect to Contacts with Government Officials?
On April 25, 2008, the Environmental Law Section presented a CLE seminar which explored some of the nuances involved in negotiations with Federal, State and Local environmental agencies. One of the questions which arose involved the interpretation of Rule 4.2 of the Pa. Rules of Professional Conduct.

Employee Benefits for Same Sex Partners - Implications of the Recent California Decision - How Your Employee Benefit Plan is Funded Matters
The California Supreme Court recently issued a decision recognizing same sex marriages and joined the growing number of states that legally recognize same sex marriages or same sex civil unions. We write this to highlight the important implications of the various state decisions recognizing same sex marriages/civil unions in the context of state and federal law, as well as clarify a confusion among certain providers who administer self funded welfare benefit plans pursuant to a ASO contract.

Increased Transparency in the Nonprofit Sector: The Redesigned Form 990
The Internal Revenue Service recently issued the final draft of its fully-redesigned Form 990, the annual return used by nonprofit organizations to report information regarding their activities. The new version of the Form 990 is designed to “enhance transparency, promote tax compliance and minimize the burden on the filing organization. As such, it dramatically differs from its predecessor in the amount of detail that nonprofits are required to report.

Protecting Your Privates - Controlling Access Across Your Right of Way
This article written by Thorp Reed attorney Eric M. Hocky for e-mail publication in the American Short Line and Regional Railroad Association's (ASLRRA) Legal Tracks Newsletter (Volume 3, Issue 1, April 18, 2008).

Product Liability Update - Spring 2008
The Spring 2008 edition of our Product Liability Update newsletter contains such articles as: "U.S. Supreme Court Holds That FDA Approval Process for Medical Devices Preempts Common Law Tort Claims," "E.D.Pa. Court Conducts Pre-Trial Review to Determine Whether Product Is Unreasonable Dangerous," "W.D.Pa. Court Limits Testimony From Plaintiff's Expert," "PA Supreme Court Grants Allocatur in Asbestos Case to Determine Whether the Court Should Adopt Section 2 of the Restatement (Third) of Torts," and more.

Now, Your "Right to Know" May Actually Mean Something in Pennsylvania: 2008 Amendment Overhauls Existing Law
February 14, 2008, Governor Rendell signed into law the Pennsylvania Right-To-Know Law, Act 3 of 2008 (Senate Bill No. 1 of 2007, Printer’s Number 1763) this new law should not be confused with the Pennsylvania Worker and Community Right-to-Know Law, 35 P.S. 7301, et seq., the latter which relates to hazardous chemical disclosure requirements in the community and workplace). The old Right-to-Know Law, the Act of June 21, 1957 (P.L. 390, No. 212) was repealed by the new legislation.

Forewarned is Forearmed - Some Reflections on the Relationship Between Counsel and the Department of Justice
When Melvyn Weiss entered a plea of guilty to racketeering charges last week, many business lawyers considered it as justice long overdue. Viewed in the light of two recent filings in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida, however, Weiss' prosecution may be just the opening salvo in the Justice Department's campaign to hold lawyers accountable for the advice they give.

Are U.S. Companies and Executives Safe When the Public Is Not? A look at FDA Enforcement in the International Arena
This article examines recent  Food & Drug Administration enforcement in the international arena, the facts giving rise to recent indictments and the legal basis for prosecution. The article also explains the legal framework that regulates food and drug imports. Finally, the article offers some proactive steps a U.S. company should take to protect the public from harmful products and themselves from criminal prosecution.

Bureau of Customs and Border Protection Proposes to Eliminate the "First Sale" as a Method of Determining the Value of Imported Merchandise
A recently published Federal Register Notice by the U.S. Bureau of Customs and Border Protection, interpreting the law by which imported merchandise is valued for Customs purposes, will reverse a 1992 Court ruling and could increase Customs duty liability for U. S. importers. Comments to the Customs proposal are returnable April 23, 2008.

Identifying the Categories of Disputes Emerging From the Subprime Meltdown
This article was written by Thorp Reed & Armstrong attorneys Robert J. Ridge and Lauren D. Rushak and published in The Subprime Crisis: A Thomson West Special Report.

Compensation and Benefits Update: Employers who Provide Welfare Benefits on a Pre-Tax Basis Must Have a Plan Document in Place by January 1, 2009 (Even Non-Profit and Public School Employees)
The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) recently issued proposed regulations under Section 125 of the Internal Revenue Code (Code). This Code provision regulates the ability of an employer to provide its employees the opportunity to receive certain, qualified benefits, on a pre-tax basis through a Cafeteria Plan, which may also be known as a Flexible Benefit Plan or § 125 Plan. The proposed regulations are intended to be effective on January 1, 2009, but employers may rely upon them now.

The WTO - How a Geneva-based Organization is Changing American Trading Rules
This article was orginally written by Thorp Reed & Armstrong attorney John P. Donohue for the Spring 2008 edition of The Beacon, a publication of the Maritime Exchange for the Delaware River and Bay.

SECCRA Landfill Expansion Case Rages on: Pennsylvania High Court takes up MPC Procedural Issue and Remands
This matter arises from a conditional use application for a landfill expansion filed in 2003 by Southeastern Chester County Refuse Authority (SECCRA). London Grove Township is the host municipality. In addition to the conditional use application, SECCRA also challenged the validity of the local zoning requirements (related to landfill setbacks and height) in an action before the Zoning Hearing Board (ZHB), and alternatively sought a variance.

Considering the Jury: Selecting an Engineer or Mechanic as an Effective Expert Witness for Trial
One of the most influential phases of trial is the presentation of expert testimony. It is highly important that a testifying expert possess the ability to convey such skill and expertise to the jury in a manner that is interesting, simple, brief, and the explanation is understandable.  When dealing with truck, tractor-trailer or motor carrier accident litigation where issues of defects to the tractor or trailer or lack of vehicle maintenance are asserted, the expert’s persona and communication skills become increasingly important. This article provides best practices for selecting an engineer or mechanic as an expert witness for trail.

Courts Continue to Struggle with the Application of the Attorney-Client Privilege to Purely Factual Communications
The attorney-client privilege does not protect facts from discovery. The privilege, however, does apply with full vigor to a client’s communication of facts to his or her lawyer. Courts have struggled with that important distinction. A recent decision from the United States Court of Federal Claims – Christofferson v. United States, 78 Fed. Cl. 810 (2007) – provides an example.

Pennsylvania Adopts Uniform Environmental ovenants Act - You Can Forget What You Learned About Equitable Servitudes
On December 18, 2007, Governor Rendell signed the Uniform Environmental Covenants Act (UECA)into law. This new statute, Act 68 of 2007, will become effective in 60 days, or on February 16, 2008. The new law was sponsored by State Representative Carole Rubley (R-Chester/Montgomery), and was designed to strengthen the control over future uses of remediated brownfields when the real estate is transferred to new wners.

Be Fair or Beware: Act with Caution when Dealing in Municipal Securities
On January 22, 2008, the Municipal Securities Rulemaking Board (MSRB) issued Notice 2008-04. The Notice urges Brokers, Dealers and Municipal Securities Dealers that execute trades for municipal bonds that carry bond insurance, to review the MSRB Rules regarding fair dealing, fair pricing, suitability and disclosure as a result of the rating agency reviews and downgrades of some bond insurers.

The Subprime Debacle Continues – The Nature and Scope of Litigation Begins to Reveal Itself
The subprime lending crisis has spawned lawsuits across the nation involving a broad cast of players and a variety of claims. Some believe that the lawsuits are just beginning and that the complete litigation “landscape” cannot yet be defined. This communique explores the types of disputes filed of record to date.

Product Liability Winter 2008
The Winter 2008 edition of our Product Liability Update features such articles as: "PA Superior Court Permits Jury to Consider Whether Byproduct of Welding Rods Establishes Existence of Defective Welding Rod," "E.D.Pa. Court Allows Discovery Relating to Products that are Not in Litigation," "E.D.Pa. Court Finds Research Organization is Potentially Liable When a Manufacturer Alters Study Results," "E.D.Pa. Court Allows Action Against Successors in Interest Under Pennsylvania's Product-Line Exception," "West Virginia Supreme Court Holds Medical Malpractice Statute Governs Product Liability Action Against Hospitals" and more.

Construction Law News - December 2007
The December edition of our newsletter for contractors, subcontractors, developers, owners and architects features such articles as "General Contractors: An Unlicensed Contractor is Fortunate to be Allowed to Indirectly Recover Payment for Work Performed When Not Properly Licensed," "What's New in Pennsylvania: Two Debarred COntractors Illustrate the Danger of Classifying Skilled Workers as Laborers on Public Works Projects," "Subcontractors: Ambiguous Provisions in Your Contract May Lead to Unintended Results," and "What's New in Ohio: Owner Entitled to Contractual Indemnification for Attorney's Fees and Costs."

Compensation and Benefits Update: New Year's Resolutions for Benefit Managers
This article provides a list of a few important examples of items that benefit managers should review in the New Year to ensure that their employee benefit plans comply with recent changes in the law.

Compensation and Benefits Update: 403(b) Model Plan Language for Public Schools
The Internal Revenue Service recently issued final Internal Revenue Code (the “Code”) § 403(b) regulations. Code § 403(b) (“§ 403(b)”) governs contributions to certain funding arrangements for employees who are working for a public school of a State or local government or a Code § 501(c)(3) tax exempt organization. The § 403(b) funding arrangements provide these employees with the opportunity for retirement savings through an employer provided plan, a § 403(b) tax sheltered annuity plan. The requirements imposed by regulations are generally effective for taxable years beginning on or after December 31, 2008.

What's New in New Jersey: Claim Against a Surety Under the Public Works Bond Act Must be Timely Filed
A supplemental article to Construction Law News written by Sunah Park, Esq. that covers New Jersey Bond Claim Requirements.

Accelerated Examination of Patents
Have an idea for a new product or process? Want to get a patent? If the normal three to five year application period is too long for you, you might consider a relatively new program offered by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (PTO). A little over a year ago, the PTO introduced an expanded Accelerated Examination program whereby an applicant who files electronically and submits the appropriate supporting documentation can expect a decision on patentability within 12 months of the date of filing.

Product Liability Update Fall 2007
The Fall 2007 edition of our Product Liability Update features such articles as "Third Circuit Refuses to Apply Delaware Consumer Fraud Act Exemption to Actions of the FDA," "W.D.Pa. Court Excludes Expert Opinion Resulting in Dismissal of Negligence Claim," "E.D.Pa. Court Finds that Admission of Defect by Product Manufacturer Binds Distributor," and more.

A Victory for Antitrust Plaintiffs: The Third Circuit Issues a Decision Limiting the Plaintiff's Burden in Robinson-Patman Act Claims
Federal court decisions over the past few years have weakened the restraints placed upon companies by the antitrust laws. In two recent examples, in Texaco Inc. v. Dagher,(Feb. 28, 2006), the United States Supreme Court opened the possibility of greater joint venture activity even in the presence of apparently collaborative joint price determinations; and in Leegin Creative Leather Products, Inc. v. PSKS, Inc., 127 S. Ct. 705 (June 28, 2007), the Supreme Court eliminated the long-standing strict per se prohibition on minimum resale price maintenance (a manufacturer’s establishment of a minimum price at which its goods may be resold).

Transportation & Logistics Update: Employer Considerations to Take into Account When Assessing Whether to Fire a Truck Driver Who was Involved in an Accident in Pennsylvania

When an employer’s driver has been involved in a motor vehicle accident that occurred during the course of employment, the employer may be forced to make decisions regarding that driver’s future with the company so as to limit its exposure to liability in the face of almost certain litigation.  Whether an employer opts to retain the driver depends on various considerations.  This article expresses considerations that an employer should take into account when assessing whether to discharge the driver who was at fault in a vehicular accident.

Thinking Outside of the Jail Cell: Pennsylvania Counties' Opportunity to Save Taxpayer Dollars through Out-Sourcing Jail Operations
State and local governments are confronted with increasing pressures to balance their budgets without raising taxes. Many Pennsylvania counties may be overlooking a genuine opportunity to reduce costs significantly by out-sourcing the operation of their jails.

Another Look at the Subprime Lending Industry: New Federal Guidelines, Among Other Proposed Changes to Federal Law, Attempt to Curtail "Risky" Practices

Banking regulators recently completed guidelines that call on lenders to strictly evaluate borrowers’ ability to repay home loans.  The tightened standards, which apply to federally regulated lenders, attempt to curtail “risky” practices that have been blamed for a record level of foreclosures in the subprime lending market.


Construction Law News - August 2007

The August edition of our newsletter for contractors, subcontractors, developers, owners and architects features such articles as "What's New in Pennsylvania: Significant Changes to Pennsylvania's Mechanics' Lien Laws," "Subcontractors: Third Circuit Court Tells 'Cautionary Tale' of Bids and Acceptance," "What's New in Ohio: Beware of and Follor Your Contract Language in Ohio," and "General Contractors: How Specific are Your Project Specifications?"


A Crash Course: Truck Accident Litigation Jury Verdicts

Thorp Reed & Armstrong, continues its efforts to educate the transportation industry and increase its awareness about potentially significant damage awards and settlements that can arise from commercial vehicle accidents in various jurisdictions. This communique contains a brief overview of various cases in Ohio, Pennsylvania, Maryland and New Jersey, all of which were decided in 2006 and 2005 and are representative of the jury verdicts rendered in those jurisdictions.


The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals Again Struck Down the Revised Hours-of-Service Rules

On July 24, 2007, a federal appeals Court in the District of Columbia struck down, for the second time in four years, the U.S. Department of Transportation’s Hours-of-Service rules that regulate and limit the number of working and driving hours for commercial truck drivers. The Court further ordered the DOT’s Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration to revise its regulations in a manner consistent with the Court’s opinion.


Loaded Interview Questions that Can Land Employers in a Load of Trouble: Avoid Common Pitfalls of Interviewing
If employers do not ensure that interviewers conduct themselves appropriately during interviews, those employers may face the time and expense of a discrimination lawsuit, even if the interviewer’s motivations for asking questions were innocent. Therefore, employers should get up speed on “loaded” interview questions to avoid.

Subprime Insolvency: Secondary Sources of Recovery, Potential Liability and Possible Opportunities to Buy Debt at Distressed Prices
As major United States based subprime lenders, such as New Century Financial, have sought bankruptcy protection, companies that have purchased debt from subprime lenders find themselves without the recourse they had depended upon when they originally purchased the debt.

Draft Redesigned Internal Revenue Service Form 990
On June 14, 2007 the Internal Revenue Service released for public comment a discussion draft of a redesigned Form 990, Return of Organizations Exempt from Income Tax, the annual return required to be filed by tax-exempt organizations to report information about their operations. The discussion draft constitutes a significant redesign of the form, which has been revised only on a piecemeal basis since 1979. The IRS anticipates using the form for the 2008 tax year (returns filed in 2009).

Understanding Recent Developments in the Subprime Lending Market
Recent developments in the subprime mortgage market have wreaked havoc on the subprime lending industry and threaten to derail the U.S. economy as a whole. Stocks fell sharply last week after reports on record-breaking mortgage defaults, heavily concentrated around subprime mortgages, unnerved investors and further exposed a troubled housing market. Financial companies’ shares were hardest hit.

Superior Court Rules That Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder is a Covered "Bodily Injury" Under Motor Vehicle Policy
In a split panel decision, the Pennsylvania Superior Court has held that an individual who observed but was not physically injured in a motor vehicle accident could recover first-party medical benefits for post-traumatic stress disorder treatment. Glickman v. Progressive Cas. Ins. Co.,2007 PA Super. 41 (Feb. 12, 2007). The Superior Court’s decision distinguished its recent ruling from a decade old opinion, Zerr v. Erie Ins. Exch., 667 A.2d 237 (Pa. Super. 1995), which held that the benefits were not recoverable.

Act 1: The Back-End Referendum; Increasing Taxes Over PDE's Published Index
The Tax Study Commission was formed, the numbers were examined, and choices were made and presented to School Boards. The Tax Study Commission was charged with making a recommendation to its Board of School Directors on whether to increase the earned income tax, or instead to impose a personal income tax, to pay for a homestead exclusion. Ultimately, that question will be asked of the voters in the May, 2007 primary.

What a Difference a Word Can Make: Omission of "All" Invalidates UIM Rejection Form
Consider this: An insurance client applies for automobile coverage and decides to reject underinsured motorist protection coverage. The insured signs and dates a form entitled “Rejection of Underinsured Motorist Protection” and readily admits that by doing so, he is rejecting underinsured motorist (“UIM”) coverage. The insured’s policy premiums are calculated so that he does not pay premiums for UIM coverage. The policy, without UIM coverage, is renewed for several years until the insured is involved in a motor vehicle accident. May the insurance company properly reject the insured’s claim for UIM benefits? In a recent Pennsylvania Superior Court decision, the answer was “No.”

PA Supreme Court Reaffirms That Insurer's Duties to Defend & Indemnify Are Triggered Solely By Complaint Allegations
In an opinion written by Chief Justice Cappy, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court reaffirmed the long-standing rule that an insurer’s duties to defend and indemnify under a comprehensive general liability (“CGL”) policy are triggered solely by the factual averments in the complaint against the insured and further held that an “accident” required to establish an “occurrence” under a CGL policy cannot be satisfied by claims based on faulty workmanship. Kvaerner Metals Div. of Kvaerner U.S., Inc. v. Commercial Union Ins. Co., et al., 908 A.2d 888 (Pa. 2006). In so holding, the Court rejected the Superior Court’s ruling that it could consider evidence outside of the complaint allegations when determining whether coverage is triggered by the claims against the insured.

Act 1 -- The Devil is in the Details
How often do you find yourself asking, as the seasons change or another birthday rolls by, “where does the time go?” Here is another mile-marker for you – did you realize, as the calendar page turns from October to November, that your Local Tax Study Commission is already middle-aged?

New Rules for Deferred Compensation and Equity Compensation Arrangements
Even if your company does not maintain any elective non-qualified deferred compensation arrangements, you may inadvertently violate Section 409A of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended, (“Code”) if you have non-qualified stock options or have granted stock appreciation rights (“SARs”) either under the terms of a plan or through individual arrangements with employees or independent contractors.

The Trademark Dilution Revision Act of 2006
On Friday, October 6, 2006 President Bush signed into law the Trademark Dilution Revision Act of 2006 (“Revision Act”). Before reviewing the Revision Act, it is important to first understand the concept of dilution and why the Federal Trademark Dilution Act (“FTDA”) needed to be revised.

United States Supreme Court to Review Recent Federal Court Decision Confirming the Preemption of State Law By Federal Statutory and Regulatory Law in the Area of Banking
Three federal courts have recently considered the issue of the federal government’s power (and the scope of that power) to preempt state law in the area of banking. Most recently in Wachovia Bank v. Watters, 431 F.3d 556 (6th Cir. 2005), the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit affirmed the holding that the National Bank Act (the "Act") and related federal regulations preempt conflicting Michigan laws governing mortgage lenders. The Court also held that the Act and regulations did not violate the Tenth Amendment of the United States Constitution, which reserves to the states those rights and powers not enumerated to the federal government.

The Pension Protection Act of 2006 -- Multiemployer Plans
For employers who are required to make contributions to multiemployer pension plans, those plans will be subject to new funding rules, generally beginning in 2008. This is as a result of the recent enactment of H.R. 4, known as the Pension Protection Act of 2006 (“PPA”). The bill was signed by President Bush on Thursday, August 17, 2006.

Compensation and Benefits Update for Plan Sponsors
While you were waiting for further guidance with respect to the deferred compensation provisions of Section 409A of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended (“Code”), Congress decided to further complicate your life.

Both the House and the Senate have passed the Pension Protection Act of 2006 (“PPA”), which is anticipated to be signed into law by President Bush during the week of August 14, 2006.

Utility Companies Liable If Do Not Use Reasonable Care
Thorp Reed & Armstrong attorney Allan L. Fluke published this article in the Constructors Association July 25, 2006 newsletter.

Local Tax Study Commission: The First Mandate of Act 1
Message to all School Boards from the Pennsylvania General Assembly: "Cut short your summer vacation – you’ve got work to do under the Taxpayer Relief Act.”

Effective June 27, 2006, Act 1 of Special Session 2006 now forces the basic rules of Act 72 onto all Pennsylvania School Districts. While the overall legislative scheme is the same, certain differences do appear. For example, under Act 72, School Boards were required to make the difficult choice of imposing additional earned income taxes in order to be eligible for the property tax relief expected from an allocation of gaming revenues. Under Act 1, all Districts will receive gaming revenues and the public through referendum, not the Board, must decide whether to augment property tax relief with a shift to increased wage (“EIT”) or personal income (“PIT”) taxes.

Recent Developments in Employee Indemnification: One Federal Court’s Attempt to Restore Balance to the Federal Criminal Justice System
In a sweeping eighty-three page opinion, a Federal trial judge recently set about correcting some of the “structural defects” of the Federal criminal justice system. According to Judge Lewis Kaplan of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York, the defects were inherent in the “Thompson Memorandum”, a set of guiding principles for Federal prosecutors issued by the Bush Justice Department in the wake of the corporate finance scandals of the early 2000’s. In an opinion that will be heralded by business executives across the country, Judge Kaplan declared unconstitutional those provisions of the Thompson memorandum that permit prosecutors, when deciding whether to indict a corporation, to consider a corporation’s decision to advance defense costs to its employees as evidence of the corporation’s willingness to cooperate with the government investigation. The Court held that the Government violates the Fifth and Sixth Amendments to the Constitution when it pressures a corporation to forego its obligations to indemnify employees for costs incurred in response to a federal probe.

Supreme Court Misses Opportunity to Clarify Scope of Federal Jurisdiction Over Wetlands
For months, developers and attorneys practicing in the area of wetlands regulation have been anticipating the U.S. Supreme Court’s decisions in the cases of Rapanos v. United States and Carabell v. United States Army Corps of Engineers. On June 19, 2006, the Supreme Court issued its decision in those consolidated cases, but the lack of a majority opinion means that the Court’s decision provides little guidance on the scope of the United States’ jurisdiction over wetlands that arguably are “adjacent to waters of the United States.”

Construction Law News -- July 2006
The July edition of our quarterly newsletter for contractors, subcontractors, developers, owners and architects features such articles as "School Construction: Contractors are Allowed to Keep Refunded Permit Fees," "Subcontractors: The Perils of Relying on Bids Without a Contract," and "General Contractors: Express Language of Subcontractor's Bid Defeats General Contractor's Claims for Breach of Contract and Promissory Estoppel."

Documentation is Essential in Establishing Whether an Agreement to Finance Exists
In a recent decision, a federal court found that evidence introduced at trial established that a defendant bank (the “Bank”) did not agree in language or conduct to provide financing to the plaintiff, a potential borrower.

The Plaintiffs, a debtor corporation and its president, brought an adversary proceeding against the Bank in a United States Bankruptcy Court in an attempt to enhance the value of the bankrupt estate. The Plaintiffs brought the action under theories of breach of written and oral contract and fraud after negotiations with the Bank for financing had been unsuccessful. The Plaintiffs voluntarily dismissed the fraud count prior to trial. Going into trial, the Plaintiffs’ position was that the Bank had breached an alleged oral and/or written agreement to provide over $3 million in financing to enable the Plaintiffs to purchase a facility that would be used to process steel. The allegations stemmed from the parties’ negotiations for the Bank to provide the Borrower with a standby letter of credit to support a loan from the Pennsylvania Economic Development and Financing Authority (“PEDFA”), as well as for a line of credit for working capital. In particular, the Plaintiffs argued that they relied on the Bank’s continued negotiations, attendance at a PEDFA pre-closing and signing of loan documents held in escrow in attempting to establish that an agreement for financing had been reached. The Plaintiffs further argued that they paid almost $73,000 in fees and costs associated with the PEDFA loan at the pre-closing in detrimental reliance on the Bank’s alleged promise to reimburse them for those expenses.

Environmental Issues: Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection Publishes Final Draft of Stormwater Best Management Practices Manual
By way of background, National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (“NPDES”) storm water permits are now required for construction activities involving the disturbance of one acre or more, as well as earth disturbances of less than one acre that occur as part of a larger common plan of development or sale of more than one acre. In Pennsylvania, these NPDES permits require the development and execution of a Post-Construction Stormwater Management Plan in addition to an Erosion and Sediment Control Plan. A Stormwater Management Plan also may be required under a municipal ordinance adopted pursuant to the Pennsylvania Stormwater Management Act (Act 167) program. In recognition of the need for guidance and consistency in the development of stormwater management plans, the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection (“DEP”) organized a committee to develop a manual setting forth “best management practices (“BMPs”) to control the volume, rate and water quality of post-construction stormwater runoff so as to protect and maintain the chemical, physical and biological properties of waters of the Commonwealth.”

Federal Contractors: New US Department of Labor Decision May Significantly Affect Federal Prevailing Wage Rates for Construction Projects
The Administrative Review Board of the U.S. Department of Labor recently ruled that the Labor Department’s Wage and Hour Division abused its discretion in determining prevailing wage rates for residential classifications in six Pittsburgh-area counties without adequately explaining the basis for the wage determinations under the Davis-Bacon Act (the “Act”) in the matter of Mistick Construction and the Associated Builders and Contractors of Western Pennsylvania, ARB Case No.: 04-051.

Construction Law News -- April 2006
The April edition of our quarterly newsletter for contractors, subcontractors, developers, owners and architects features such articles as "Contract Interpretation: The Clear Language of a Contract Trumps the Discovery Rule for Latent Defects," "What's New on the Gulf Coast: Compliance with Bidding Laws on Publicly Owned Projects," and "What's New in Pennsylvania: What Constitutes 'Public Work' Under the Pennsylvania Prevailing Wage Act?"

State Supreme Court Expands Potential Liability for Premises Owners in Products Liability Lawsuits

The New Jersey Supreme Court extended the potential liability of premises owners by holding that landowners may be liable to third parties who never set foot on the actual premises. Olivo v. Owens-Illinois, Inc. This decision arose from a wrongful death/survival action in which the plaintiff, a former steamfitter/welder sought damages for the death of his spouse.


American Academy of Neurology Toughens Guidelines for Expert Witness Testimony
The American Academy of Neurology issued new guidelines effective January 10, 2006, regarding expert witness testimony by its members. According to the Academy, the new guidelines are a response to several complaints by physicians about unqualified expert witnesses. The Academy’s goal in enacting the new guidelines is to promote accurate testimony by neurologists and to ensure they have expertise in the area of their testimony.

New Environmental Due Diligence Rule Will Require Greater Effort, Time and Coordination
A recent U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (“EPA”) regulation will have a significant impact on the way in which environmental due diligence activities are conducted for property acquisitions. On November 1, 2005, the EPA published its All Appropriate Inquiries Rule (“AAI Rule”), which establishes standards and practices for the performance of “all appropriate inquiries” in order to qualify for the innocent landowner, bona fide prospective purchaser or contiguous property owner defenses under the Federal Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act (“CERCLA”).(1) These defenses provide liability relief, for those who qualify, from the strict liability imposed by CERCLA on current owners of property contaminated with hazardous substances.

California Courts Will Not Enforce Waiver of Right to Jury Trial Obtained Pre-Litigation
Companies often use “jury waiver” provisions in their agreements to take advantage of the reduced expense and limited delay associated with bench trials. Such waivers also give companies the ability to avoid the expense and loss of appeal rights associated with arbitration. In a recent decision, the California Supreme Court acknowledged these benefits of contractual jury waivers and then declared the waivers to be invalid. As a result, companies using jury waiver provisions will no longer get the benefit of their bargain in California state court unless the California legislature acts to modify the law.

Construction Law News - January 2006
The January edition of our quarterly newsletter for contractors, subcontractors, developers, owners and architects features such articles as "Liquidation Agreements: Design Professionals are not Untouchable in the Absence of Contractual Privity," "Florida Court: Provides No Relief for 9/11 Delay Damages and Strict Construction of a Claim For Damages Under Eichleay Formula," "Developers: EPA Publishes All Appropriate Inquiries Rule for Landowner Liability Protection," and more.

Recent Court Decision Favors Defendants' Choice of Venue Under the Class Action Fairness Act
In a new decision, the United States District Court for the Southern District of Georgia ruled in favor of allowing Defendants to remove a case to Federal Court under the Class Action Fairness Act (CAFA). By allowing removal to Federal Court, Defendants will be able to avoid trying cases in front of “local juries” who may be prejudiced toward out of state corporations.

In Your Court - November 2005
The November edition of our litigation newsletter features such articles as "Are Your Secrets Confidential, and Will a Court Agree?," Trademark Infringement - Looking Beyond The Direct Infringer," "The Importance of Preserving Potential Evidence," and more.

Construction Law News - October 2005
The October edition of our quarterly newsletter for contractors, subcontractors, developers, owners and architects features such articles as "What's New in Pennsylvania: Recent Cases Considering the Validity of Bid Protests," Arbitration: Think Twice Before Agreeing to Arbitrate as Your Appeal Rights are Extremely Limited," and more.

Physicians Should Be Advised to Obtain Written Expert Witness Fee Agreements
In Jefferson v. Toyota Motor Manufacturing, West Virginia, Inc., et al. (S.D. W. Va., Case No. 2:03-CV-02345), plaintiff’s counsel requested a deposition from the plaintiff’s treating physician. The physician required payment in the amount of $350 per hour, with $700 payable in advance for two hours of deposition time. Plaintiff’s counsel paid the physician $350, proposing a one hour telephonic deposition, and asked defense counsel to pay for any time over one hour. The physician then informed the plaintiff’s lawyer that because she had not treated the plaintiff (patient) in over two years, she would need to review the plaintiff’s medical records for 15 to 20 minutes prior to the deposition, and she intended to charge for this time.

Clients and Counsel Beware: Harsh Penalties Ahead for Failure to Comply with Discovery Obligations
Evidenced by recent orders in Dauphin County, Pennsylvania, and from a monumental ruling earlier this year in Florida, courts are increasingly becoming less tolerant of companies and their counsel who fail to comply with the rules of discovery. Penalties are becoming drastic and are dramatically impacting the evidence that parties may introduce at trial.

Construction Law News - August 2005
The August edition of our quarterly newsletter for contractors, subcontractors, developers, owners and architects features articles such as: "Execute A Written Contract: Define Your Intent Or Pay Without Receiving Any Benefit", "Indemnification/Insurance Coverage Language: Do Not Overrate Your Coverage" and "What's New in Ohio and New Jersey."

West Virginia Supreme Court Rules That Alleged Defects in Pre-Suit Notice of Claim and Screening Certificate of Merit Do Not Warrant Dismissal of Plaintiff's Lawsuit
In Hinchman v. Gillette, ___ S.E. 2d ___, ___ W. Va. ___ (No. 31760) (2005), the West Virginia Supreme Court (“WVSCA”) ruled that a defendant healthcare provider cannot challenge the legal sufficiency of a plaintiff’s pre-suit notice of claim or screening certificate of merit under W. Va. Code 55-7B-6 (2003), unless the plaintiff was given specific written notice of, and an opportunity to address and correct, the alleged defects and insufficiencies.

Recent West Virginia Supreme Court Decision Declares Portions of Medical Professional Liability Act Unconstitutional
In Louk v. Cormier, ___ S.E.2d ___, ___ W. Va. ___ (No. 31773) (2005), the West Virginia Supreme Court (“WVSCA”) declared unconstitutional a recent amendment to the Medical Professional Liability Act (“MPLA”). The amendment at issue required twelve person juries, and permitted those juries to return non-unanimous verdicts.

Construction Law News - March 2005
The March edition of our quarterly newsletter for contractors, subcontractors, developers, owners and architects features articles such as: "The Pennsylvania Supreme Court Creates An Open Season On Architects And Other Design Professionals" and "Multi-Prime Contracts Must Be Awarded For Public School Buildings."

What's New in Ohio: The Standard To Determine Substantial Completion
The Court of Appeals of Ohio recently issued a decision which sets forth the standard to determine whether a contractor or subcontractor has substantially completed its contract work.

What’s New In Land Use: Commonwealth Court Limits “Unnecessary Hardship” Analysis For Dimensional Variance Requests
In Hertzberg v. Zoning Board of Adjustment, 721 A.2d 43 (Pa. 1998), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court held that a more relaxed standard of “unnecessary hardship” could justify the grant of dimensional variances...

Pennsylvania Supreme Court Partially Solidifies the Claim of Negligent Misrepresentation Under Pennsylvania Law
A recent Pennsylvania Supreme Court decision may support negligence liability for misrepresentations made by entities or individuals in the course of their business dealings, as well as for misrepresentations made by professionals engaged in the business of supplying information.

New Rules For "Deferred Compensation:" What's Covered and What's Not?
A new Section of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 was added by the American Jobs Creation Act of 2004, requiring “deferred compensation plans” to now comply with new distribution, election and funding rules.

The Class Action Fairness Act of 2005: School Is Out For Class Action Lawsuits and Plaintiffs' Attorneys Who File Them
On February 18, 2005, President Bush signed into law the Class Action Fairness Act, marking a systemic shift in the American judicial system and the end of a decades-long quest to reign in class action lawsuits across America.

In Your Court - March 2005
The March edition of our quarterly litigation newsletter features articles such as "Proof Of Absence Of Confusion Is Not Good Faith Defense To Trademark Infringement," "Employers Beware: Commercial General Liability Policy May Not Protect From Employee Lawsuits," and "Full And Accurate Disclosure: Protecting The Rights Of Businesses To Commercial Information."

Recent Ohio Supreme Court Decision Finds Medical Monitoring Claims Inappropriate For Class Action Certification
The Ohio Supreme Court has recently issued a ruling which will help defendants defeat class certification in many medical monitoring claims.

West Virginia Human Rights Act: Is Your Workplace in Compliance? A Review and Reminder of the Major Theories of Liability Under the Human Rights Act
The West Virginia Human Rights Act continues to play an important role in workplaces throughout the State of West Virginia. All covered employers should review their policies and practices to ensure the compliance of those policies and procedures with the applicable provisions of the law.

Compensation and Benefits Client Alert: Involuntary Distributions and Automatic Rollover Requirements for Distributions Made On or After March 28, 2005
These new automatic rollover requirements apply to all tax-qualified plans under 401(a) of the Code, 403(b) plans, governmental 457(b) plans and church plans.

FDIC Further Restricts Payday Lending by Forbidding Some Repeat Loans
Under the FDIC's new guidelines, FDIC-supervised institutions involved in the payday loan industry are subject to an affirmative duty to “ensure that payday loans are not provided to customers who had payday loans outstanding at any lender" for a specified amount of time.

West Virginia Supreme Court Puts Limits on Class Actions for Medical Monitoring
In a significant precedent-setting decision, the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals halted out-of-state plaintiffs' efforts to file claims for medical monitoring in West Virginia.

Responding to GIC Investigations
By being prepared and responding effectively, your company can minimize the intrusion associated with responding to a government investigation.

The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration is Reviewing and Reconsidering its Recently Adopted Hours-of-Service Rules
In January 2005, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration published a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking in order to re-examine the 2003 Hours-of-Service rules.

First Pennsylvania Court Ruling on Legality of "Check Cashing" Payday Loan Enterprises Which Were Targeted by Attorney General in 1999 Investigation
In a recent ruling on a case involving a payday loan business, a judge held, possibly for the first time in Pennsylvania, that a payday lender using the "check cashing" system of operation had been making short-term loans, and therefore the company's activites had fallen within the purview of Pennsylvania's usury law.

The Use of an Unambiguous Disclaimer May Help Hospitals Prevail in Apparent Agency Claims
The West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals recently issued a ruling which may help hospitals avoid apparent agency claims outside the emergency room setting.

Trademark Law Update: What’s In A Name
Selecting a mark that functions as a trademark looks to be a rather simple task. Looks, however, can be deceiving and great care should be taken in selecting a mark.

Township’s Business Privilege Tax Unconstitutional
The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has held that a business privilege tax that fails to apportion receipts by in-state and out-of-state commerce violates the Commerce Clause of the United States Constitution...

Construction Law News - December 2004
The December edition of our quarterly newsletter for contractors, subcontractors, developers, owners and architects features articles such as: "Land Use: Michigan Decision Casts Doubt On Use Of Eminent Domain” and “Recent Interpretations Of The Pennsylvania Mechanics’ Lien Law"

Construction Law News - September 2004
The September edition of our quarterly newsletter for contractors, subcontractors, developers, owners and architects features articles such as: "Bid Protests: Do Not Get Caught On Treacherous Footing" and "Liens: Final Means Final!"

SEC Proposed Rule-Making: Registration of Hedge Fund Advisers
On July 20th, the SEC released the text of its proposed new rule and rule amendments regarding "hedge funds."

Construction Law News - June 2004
The June edition of our quarterly newsletter for contractors, subcontractors, developers, owners and architects features articles such as: “Who May Successfully File A Miller Act Claim?” and “Who Is A Responsible Bidder?”

Records Management: A Critical Concern for Businesses of All Sizes
In today’s business and legal climate, there is no viable alternative to an effective records management program. The risks of failure to address records management issues, including drastic legal consequences and prohibitive costs, are too great to ignore.

Construction Law News - March 2004
The March edition of our quarterly newsletter for contractors, subcontractors, developers, owners and architects features articles such as: “Can a Project Manager’s Signature Prevent a Lawsuit” and “Do Not Let Others Do Your Bidding.”

Subprime Mortgage Lender and Servicers Beware!
The country’s largest servicer of “subprime” home mortgages has reached a preliminary agreement to settle claims of “predatory” servicing that could cost it upwards of $55 million. On November 12, 2003, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) reached settlements with Fairbanks Capital Holding Corp., its wholly-owned subsidiary Fairbanks Capital Corp. (collectively, Fairbanks), and Thomas D. Basmajian, the founder and former CEO of Fairbanks, to settle serious allegations of predatory servicing of subprime mortgage loans. The settlement will resolve a sweeping complaint filed against Fairbanks in the federal district court of Massachusetts, and will be coordinated with a related settlement in a class action consolidating four suits in California.

Construction Law News - December 2003
The December edition of our quarterly newsletter for contractors, subcontractors, developers, owners and architects features articles such as: “A Material Supplier Is Not Covered by a Roofer’s Insurance Policy” and “Penalties and Attorneys’ Fees Found to Be Not Waiveable Under the Pennsylvania Contractor and Subcontractor Payment Act.”

SEC Custody Rules Affecting Advisers
The Securities and Exchange Commission recently made the first significant revisions to its custody rule for investment advisers since the rule was adopted more than 40 years ago.

Construction Law News - September 2003
The September edition of our quarterly newsletter for contractors, subcontractors, developers, owners and architects features articles such as: “Silence Is Not Contract Acceptance: Do Not Begin Work Until Your Contract Is Executed” and “Left Out in the Cold: Bid Win Turns into Loss for HVAC Sub-subcontractor.”

Transportation and Logistics Update: New FMCSA Exemption for Diabetic Drivers
As of September 22, 2003, diabetic truck and bus drivers are able to apply for an exemption from the medical restrictions contained in the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations (FMCSRs). On September 2, 2003, the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) announced its decision to begin granting case-by-case exemptions for certain insulin-using, interstate commercial drivers, otherwise restricted from operating a commercial vehicle in interstate commerce.

U.S. Supreme Court Demarcates Liability Under Federal Copyright and Unfair Competition Law
The Supreme Court of the United States recently provided businesses with further guidance on how best to protect their intellectual property. In Dastar Corp. v. Twentieth Century Fox Film Corp., the Court articulated certain distinctions in the protections and liability imposed under federal copyright and unfair competition law.